Featured

Re-think your design with Design Thinking

th0NQXLXV0.jpg

Sometimes products run out of traction in the market, because all products look the same and hardly any innovation takes place. In this situation it can be beneficial to re-design a product in order to create a new impact in the market. Design Thinking is an effective approach to help you doing this. The result can be break-through products with a fresh look and new surprising functionalities, which are based on deep user insights and help you to differentiate in the market. This blog discusses why Design Thinking fits in the toolkit of every innovator.

The origin of Design Thinking

Design Thinking is a design method which helps to re-design your product, working from the perspective of the user. Frequently, it is also called human-centered design. The basics of this approach is known for decades, but the method gained traction outside the design community by an article called ‘Design Thinking’ by Tim Brown, CEO of the design company IDEO (see reference 1). Since then, the approach has been applied to designing a whole range of new products and services, but also to solve business problems in general. Examples of business problems are the design of a new supply chain for an e-commerce business, or the selection of a marketing strategy for a consumer goods company. The Design Thinking approach is used by large corporations competing in mature markets, but also by start-ups which have the ambition to disrupt the market. The approach is also taught in the form of workshops by a number of schools and universities, such as the Stanford D-School and MIT Sloan (see reference 2).

The Design Thinking process

The Design Thinking method consists of a number of simple steps. These process steps are ideally done in a series of workshops with participants from several disciplines: industrial design, user interaction design, mechanical engineering, industrial engineering, product management and so on. Ideally, participants, of all disciplines who work on the product, take part in these workshops. Participants are asked to give priority to the workshops, so that all disciplines are present. It is recommended to use an independent facilitator to manage the process, allowing the participants to focus on the content. The workshops can be done in a relatively short period of time, e.g. 1-2- weeks. The steps followed are described below.

Empathize

In this phase research is conducted to develop an understanding of your users. This is best done by observing and interviewing users using the products in real life. So visit customers in the home when you want to learn about household appliances, or in the office when you want to learn about professional IT. It is important to put your pre-conceptions aside. It is recommended to work with multiple observers, because observers have different viewpoints and observe different things. It is also important to interview and understand other stakeholders, like people selling the product or providing customer service.

Define

In this phase all participants should come together to collect all observations and all other research to reach conclusions. In this phase the user group is defined, what they want to achieve, what pain points and challenges they have.

Explore

In this phase one or more workhsops are organised, to generate possible solutions. Ideas may be crazy, creative ideas. In this phase it is important to think out-of-the-box, to ensure that new, break-through solutions, are generated.  This is also called creative brainstorming. The aim of this phase is to generate multiple innovative solutions, to compare them, and to prioritize them.

Prototype

In this phase prototypes or physical representations of the ideas are built. Prototypes do not necessarily have to be a working product. For instance, to collect ideas about a new website, a set of drawings can be made, collecting feedback about the main ideas, before putting effort in difficult coding work.

Test

Next the prototypes are tested with real users, in order to collect feedback. Based on this feedback, quick iterations are made, to collect further feedback and iterate fast to the best solution. Ultimately, the ideas are implemented in real products through the regular deployment mechanisms. For hardware products this involves detailed design, training, tooling and ramping up. Now, the effect of the changes can be measured in the market.

Benefits of Design Thinking

In the past years, I have applied the Design Thinking rationale in several ways, for products, services and business problems. I am very much an advocate of this method because of a number of reasons.

First of all, I like the outside-in approach of it. It is a systematic method which helps designers and engineers to think from perspective of the customer. This increases the chance of success in the market. This is especially valuable in high-tech or science based businesses, where people tend to think from perspective of the product or technology and not so much from perspective of the user.

Second, I like this method because it is ideally done in the teams which are responsible for the product. Because people have contributed to the outcome, it increases the commitment in the organization to make the outcome a success.

Third, I like this method because it is based on quick iterations and fast testing with real users, allowing for fast convergence and risk reduction. This corresponds very much with other popular methods, like the Lean Startup method and Agile product development.

Fourth, Design Thinking it is ideally done in a number of workshops which can be done in a relatively short period of time (e.g. 1-2 weeks). Impact can be achieved in a relatively short period of time. When a company is practicing Agile or Scrum, it ideally fits in 1 or 2 sprints.

Fifth, I like this method, because the method is generally applicable. Design Thinking can be used for products, services and business problems, like the design of a new supply chain for e-commerce.

Finally, the method is complementary to other methods described in this blog, like the Value Proposition and the Voice of the Customer Tree. Whereas the Value Proposition and Voice of the Customer Tree focus on the WHAT (product proposition and key requirements) of a new product or service, Design Thinking focusses on the HOW (technical solutions to achieve benefits). The Value Proposition and Voice of the Customer Tree can be used a draft input, which can be further refined with the outcomes of the Design Thinking process.

Summary

This blog discusses the Design Thinking methodology. Design Thinking is a structured, outside-in design approach, which helps you to create break-through products, based on deep customer understanding. The method can be applied to products, services or wider business problems. The method consists of a number of steps, which are ideally done in a series of workshops by multi-functional teams. The method can be done in a relatively short period of time. The method is complementary to a number of other methods presented in this blog, like the Value Proposition and Voice of the Customer Tree.

References

  1. ‘Design Thinking’, Tim Brown, Harvard Business Review, 2008
  2. ‘Design Thinking, explained’, Rebecca Linke, Blog MIT Sloan, September 14th, 2017

How to launch your product in the market?

There are many businesses which have developed a great new product or service, but do not know how to successfully launch this product in the market. That is because their main expertise is technical and in developing new products, or because they are a startup which never went through the process of launching a product in the market. Traditionally the Marketing Mix based on the 4P’s (Product, Price, Place, Promotion) is used as a framework to determine your marketing strategy and plans. This model has been developed by professor Jerome McCarthy in 1960 (ref 1). But is the digital age, marketing has changed due to new digital channels and tools, like mobile apps, social media and chatbots. For the modern marketeer it is essential to understand the potential of digital tools and how to integrate them in the marketing mix. This article gives an overview of the various elements to be considered, to effectively launch your product in the market.

Product

The term ‘product’ refers to the physical goods or services offered to meet the customer needs. It consists of the basic product or service, but also the extended product, which includes additional aspects like the packaging of a product, the after sales service, warranties and the brand value for the customer. In this part you need to address the following questions:

  • Description of the customer. Is the customer a business or a consumer? Is the customer a buyer or the user of the product? Are there other stakeholders who play a role in the purchase decision?
  • What are the customer needs the product addresses?
  • What are the product benefits to meet those needs?
  • What are the Unique Selling Points (USP’s) which alone or in combination differentiate the product from offers by the competition?
  • What are the critical-to-value requirements (CTV’s) for a product to deliver on its promise? Think about its functional requirements but also about requirements like product quality, reliability, security and design for sustainability.
  • What are requirements for the extended product? Think about consumables, packaging, customer service, warranties, loyalty programs, after sales service.

Successful products have been tested in advance and sometimes many iterations took place to make sure that there is a product-market fit. This means that the product benefits meet the needs of the target customers in a specific market. Also, they have been technically tested to make sure that the product works properly, and that the product is secure and reliable over time.

Price

The term ‘price’ refers to the financial price and payment model to buy the product. In this part you address the following questions:

  • What is the initial price of the product and is the customer prepared to pay this price?
  • How do you expect the price to develop this price over time?
  • What is the payment model of the product? Is it a one-time transaction, a business model based on consumables or a subscription model for services?
  • How do prices vary for different product models or service tiers?
  • Do you want to offer any discounts for initial customers?
  • Do you want to charge a price for after sales service?

To determine the optimal price, quantitative tests can be done with potential customers. In these tests various prices are proposed, and the number of customers is measured which are willing to buy the product for these prices. These data can be plotted in a so-called price sensitivity curve which shows the price versus the willingness to pay. This curve is then used to determine the optimum price, where the total revenue (price x number of customers) is optimal.

Successful products meet 2 important conditions. First, they charge a price which is low than the perceived value for the customer. This means that the customer is prepared to buy the product. Second, the price of the product is higher than the costs to produce the product and the organisational costs to deliver and sell the product. This means that financial value is created for the business which can be used to re-invest or returned to its investors.

Place

Place refers to deciding which distribution channels to use to deliver the product to the customer. This does not only involve physical channels, like retail shops, but also online channels, like web shops or online marketplaces. It is essential to be present in the channels which the customer is using, with the right offer at the right moment. If you are in the wrong channels or at the wrong time, you will not reach your customers and you will not be able to sell your product. In this part you address the following questions:

  • What channels is the customer using to buy your kind of product? Consider the entire sales funnel: awareness, consideration, purchase, product delivery and after sales service. Since the advent of the internet the number of channels has increased considerably. It is important to consider all channels: retail shops, distributors, websites, mobile apps, TV apps, social media channels, email, personal messages (like SMS). It can be that multiple channels are used for a certain stage. For instance, awareness for a product can be created via email or social media, while the purchase can happen in a physical store or in a web shop. A great help is to make a table with on one axis the stages of the purchase funnel and on the other axis the channels which can be used by the customer. Then mark with crosses which channel is used for which stage of the purchase process.
  • What channels do you select for your business? Define what channels you would like to use to sell your product. Depending on your business strategy it can be that you want to restrict the number of channels, for instance that you choose to be an online player only to save distribution costs.
  • How does the customer journey look? Describe the different steps that a customer has to go through: orientation, product selection, product ordering, product delivery, product activation, product use and product service.
  • Are people in the channels sufficiently trained to sell and service the product? Is all the relevant product information available?
  • For businesses which operate internationally, also decide in which countries you would like to be active. For growing enterprises this can be a phased approach: you start in one country and gradually expand to other markets.

Promotion

This refers to deciding how you would like to promote your product. You can have the right product and be present in the right channels, but when the customer does not know about the product or the benefits, the customer will not buy it. In this part you address the following questions:

  • What kind of promotions are used in your market segment? Think about TV advertising, billboards, advertisement in magazines or newspapers, social media ads.
  • Do you want to promote my product passively or do active marketing campaigns?
  • Do you want to release any press statements?
  • Do you want to work with advertising or online agencies to promote your product?
  • Do you want to use any celebrity promoters, product endorsers or influencers?
  • What are the estimated costs for your promotional activities, and do they fit into the marketing budget?

Alternative models beyond the 4P’s

Over time there have been several proposals to extend the traditional model with additional P’s beyond the original model of 4P’s. Proposals are to include People, Process and Physical Evidence. It is the view of the author that this is not needed, because as demonstrated above, the 4P’s perfectly cover all new developments. Extending the marketing mix beyond the 4P’s only makes the framework more complex.

Writing a Marketing Plan

A Marketing Plan gives the complete overview of how a product is introduced to the market or how a product is promoted when the product is already available. It is a helpful tool to make sure that everybody in an organization is aligned about what must be achieved and how to do that. A good Marketing Plan consists of the following topics:

  • A description of the business goals you would like to achieve. These goals must be concrete, measurable goals, which can be measured to decide on the effectiveness of your marketing strategy. Some examples of goals: product x must reach a market share of 10% within 3 years after launch, the awareness of this new feature must be 25% amongst target users, in 20% of the sales customers buy extended service with the product.
  • A description of the marketing strategy. This is a basically a description of the 4P’s. The marketing strategy must support the overall business strategy of the company.
  • A description of the time plan, which describes which activity is happening when and how this links to the goals to be achieved.
  • A description of the resources needed to execute the plan. It includes an overview of the amount of people needed for execution of the plan, including external resources, like advertisement agencies. It also includes the financial budget which is needed to execute the plan. Without the right amount of people and resources, the plan cannot be executed.

Conclusion

Innovative companies frequently have problems to launch their products in the market. The Marketing Mix based on the 4P’s of Product, Price, Place and Promotion is an effective framework to describe how you would like to promote and sell your product in the market. In the digital age, traditional ways to sell your products have changed. Many new options are available to promote and sell your product. This article gives an overview of different options to consider when launching your product. When you have implemented and aligned all elements of the marketing mix, you increase the chance of commercial success.

References

  1. McCarthy, J.: Basic Marketing: A managerial approach, 13de edition, Irwin, Homewood Illinois, 2001 (first edition 1960)

How to Manage Risk in Innovation

Innovation is a risky activity. There are many examples of technologies or products which failed in the market. Also there are many examples of innovative companies which failed or went bankrupt. So the question is what can be done to minimize risk in the innovation process? This blog discusses the concept of risk, how to measure risk and what can be done to minimize risk. This theory can be applied both to innovation projects in large companies, as well as innovation which is done by startup companies.

The concept of risk

In simple terms, risk in innovation is change that an undesirable outcome occurs. Undesirable outcomes in innovation could be a technology that does not provide the expected benefits, a newly developed product or service which is hard to sell or a startup company which does not deliver the expected financial profits and goes bankrupt. According to an international study carried out by Startup Genome (1), only 1 in 12 startups become a sustainable business. Risk is caused by uncertainty about the conditions which cause the undesirable outcomes. For instance it is unclear whether a certain technology is able to meet specific product requirements or it is unclear whether a new product meets the requirements of the customers.

Analogy: throwing of a dice

Let’s assume we are playing a board game and need to throw a 6 in order to win the game. When we throw the dice it is unknown what number the outcome will be. We just know that there is a certain chance that the outcome will be the desired outcome 6 but that there is also a high chance that the outcome will be a lower number than 6. We do not know what is needed to throw the dice in such a way that the outcome would be 6. When we would throw the dice a lot of times we would probably discover that there is roughly 1/6 chance that we would reach the desired outcome of 6 and 5/6 chance that we would end up with a lower number than 6.

Let’s now further assume we would have a very sophisticated computer program in which we could make a so-called ‘finite-element’ model of the dice and the board of the game. Let’s assume we could exactly model the position of the dice in the air, the mass distribution inside the dice, the characteristics of the surface of the board etc. Then we would be able to calculate the exact trajectory and movement of the dice until it reaches its final position on the board. With this program we would be able to determine the exact start position and speed with which we need to throw the dice in order to reach the desired outcome of 6.

The throwing of a dice is in a way similar to the management of an innovation project. Risks occur because we do not have the right information about what is happening in our environment, how it is going to affect us and how we can control the outcome. We can now reduce risk by gathering knowledge and make decisions to influence the outcome positively.       

Choosing the right growth strategy

The first step is to decide where to play. In order to grow a company could develop new products or enter new markets, do both or continue to push its current products in the existing market. This is illustrated by the well-known Ansoff Matrix (2), see below.

ansoff-matrix_291220

All quadrants have different risk profiles. When a company chooses to develop a new product the risk is higher than when a company improves existing products. This is because there are unknown factors, like customer acceptance or the feasibility of new technologies. When a company chooses to enter a new market the risk is also higher than when a company chooses to stay in the same market. Also here there are a number of unknown factors, like the reaction of competitors, or the acceptance of the product. When a company chooses to develop a new product and enter a new market at the same time, there is clearly a higher risk because of the combined risks of developing a new product and entering a new market. The risks are summarized the table below:

Minimizing project risk

Once we have decided what our growth strategy is, we can now look at the risk of a specific project. Projects can have different types of risk as illustrated in the table below, which shows some typical risk categories. Project risks can be minimized by performing certain activities which are meant to generate knowledge and make decisions to reduce negative outcomes.

To reduce risk over time, typically a stage-gated process is used, to focus on solving critical answers and reducing project risk over time. For each specific gate, there must be certain information available, in order to pass to the next phase. Examples of project phases are: the technology development phase, the product development phase, the industrialization phase, the market introduction phase. In each phase, certain project information is collected and decisions are made re that specific phase. Examples of decisions are for instance: which technology to use, where to source the components of a product, where to produce the product and what is the initial target market segment of a product. The result is that over the course of a project the amount of information about a product is growing, while the risk is reduced, see the graph below.   

Knowledge versus risk_291220

Performing a risk analysis

Within the risk categories, there are many specific risks which need to be identified, in order to prevent them from occurring. One way to do this is to perform a risk analysis. The best way to perform a risk analysis is by organizing a risk analysis workshop with the key stakeholders of the project. For this it is important to identify those stakeholders of the project who have the best understanding of possible risks which might occur. Then invite them for a workshop, which could typically last a day, depending on the complexity of the project. The first step is to identify and list all the potential risks. It is important to have all stakeholders together, because participants can trigger each other when they mention specific risks. In this way it is ensured that no important risks are overlooked. The next step is to identify the likelihood of occurrence for each specific risks. As initial step, the likelihood can be classified as low, medium or high. In the next step the impact of the risk is identified. The impact is the negative effect when a certain risk occurs. The impact of a risk can also be classified as low, medium or high. Both the likelihood and impact are determined with the whole group, because each individual participant can have different ideas about them. When the likelihood and impact are classified, the severity of the risk can be calculated by multiplying the likelihood and the impact. As first step the severity can be also classified as low, medium or high. Now the risks can be placed in order of severity, with the risks with the highest severity on top, followed by risks with medium severity and the risks with low severity at the bottom.  

Now the risk are identified and ranked according to their severity, it is very important to address them in the project. I call this ‘risk confrontation’. This requires a pro-active approach from the people involved in the project. When risks are not pro-actively addressed, nothing will happen, and chances are high that some of the risks will occur. This starts with determining mitigating measures. These are measures which minimize or prevent the risk from happening. It is the best to determine these measures with all stakeholders, because different people can have different perceptions about what is needed to minimize a specific risk. The final step is to make people responsible to address these risks. Otherwise there is a risk that nobody takes any action, so there risk is not reduced. In this step those persons are selected who are best suited to manage a certain risk. When the risk is a technical risk, the best person is probably a development engineer. When the risk is a commercial risk, the best person is probably a commercial product manager or a marketing manager. To execute a risk reduction workshop, it is recommended to use a standard template to list all the results of the workshop, so that all the actions can be followed up in the project. The graph below gives an example of a project risk analysis template which can be used.

Summary

Innovation is a risky activity. Risk in innovation is the chance that an unfavorable outcome occurs. Project risk can be reduced by systematically taking out uncertainties out of the development process. The first step is to know where to play. This means to choose between developing new products or new markets or both. Each project involves certain risks. Now risks can be reduced by following a stage-gated process in which per phase activities are done to generate knowledge and make decisions in order to reduce risks. By following this process, the knowledge is growing and risk is reduced over time. Finally a risk analysis can be done to identify and reduce some specific risks. The best way is to perform a risk analysis workshop with different stakeholders of the project. By identifying risks, rank their severity and define mitigating measures, the risks of a project can be reduced considerably.     

References

  1. https://startupgenome.com/reports/global-startup-ecosystem-report-2019
  2. The Ansoff Matrix was developed by professor Igor Ansoff (1918-2002)

How to create Value by Addressing your Existing Customers

When selling products or services, most people think about selling to new customers. This is especially the case for companies with a new product or service. However, value can also be created by selling to existing customers. Selling to existing customers is much more efficient than selling to new customers. This blog explains how value can be created by selling to existing customers. A company which sells to existing customers can grow much faster with lower costs.  

Creating Customer Value

Value is created when products or services are sold to customers. The total customer value created is the number of customers x the average value per customer. So there are two ways to create value. The first way is to sell products to new customers. This is what most companies focus on, especially new companies. But selling to existing customers is expensive, because customers have to be reached, informed and converted into satisfied customers. When the company is successful, there is a growing base of existing customers. Now there is the potential to create additional value, which is to also sell products to existing customers. This way to create value is frequently overlooked. Selling to existing customers is cheaper than selling to new customers, because these customers are already aware of the company, its products or their services. Existing customers don’t need to be convinced anymore about the added value and quality of the product. So no expensive sales campaigns are needed to create awareness for the product. Also it is easier and faster for a company to reach those customers, in particular when the company has the contact information available, for instance via customer accounts. When these customers are already satisfied customers, the costs to sell more products is much lower than for new customers. So it is much easier to create additional value from existing customers than to create value from selling to new customers.

Ways to create value with existing customers

There are several ways to create value with existing customers. They are listed below:

Up-selling: up-selling is when you sell the customer a more expensive product or service than what the customer has in its mind. Examples are the sale of a more expensive phone with more memory, the sale of a more expensive car with a sports package or the sale of a more expensive package in a video app.

Cross-selling: cross-selling is when you sell additional products or services with the product you are selling. Common examples are the sales of luxury items, like sunglasses or watches, with a luxury car; the sales of a rental car with the booking of a hotel, or the sales of additional insurance with the sales of a laptop computer.  

Renewal-selling: renewal-selling is when you sell to customers new products to replace older products. Examples are a mobile phone company which sells new product models to replace older models, or a software company which sells new software to replace older versions of the software. Sometimes a company offers an incentive to exchange older products by newer ones, for instance by offering a price reduction on the new product.

Referral-selling: referral-selling is when you encourage existing customers to promote products or services to friends or family. In such a way existing customers act as your salesman/women.

Data-selling: another way to create value, especially for digital services, is to collect data from customer interactions, and to sell those data to 3rd parties, for instance advertisers. It is important to realise that frequently there are legal constraints of doing this, for instance the customer has to approve that him/her usage data is being used.

These are all different ways to create more value with your existing customers. But what are proven practices which can be applied?

Common practices to increase customer value

There are several common practices which can be used to create more sales with your existing customers. Some of these can be used in traditional brick-and-mortar businesses, and some a very common with online businesses.  

Smart pricing: this is when a company creates financial incentives to realize more sales. An example is the sale of lamps or batteries. Frequently there are value packs with multiple products which are priced in such a way that the average prices per product is lower. But the average price is still above the cost price, so that the company makes more money.

Voucher codes: this method is similar to the one above. Customers get voucher codes to buy more products or try product extensions. This method is frequently used by online services, like video services.

App push messages or email notifications: this is to notify existing customers when there are new products available. This is to stimulate additional sales of new products. This method is also frequently used by online services, like food ordering services or travel services.

Digital newsletters or magazines: this is to inform existing customers about events, new products, product upgrades etc. The goal of newsletters or magazines is to create loyalty with existing customers and to stay top of mind, so that it is easier to sell additional products to them.

Customer events: these are events for existing customers, like webcasts or workshops, to help existing customers to get more out of the product and to inform them about product upgrades and new products.

There are many more practices to create additional sales with existing customers, but the examples above should give you some inspiration about what you could do for your particular business.

Creating ambassadors

When customers are happy with the products and services, they become more loyal to the company and start to promote its products and act as ambassadors for the company*. A large base of ambassadors is a very valuable asset for a company, because these customers act as sales people, without the need to pay them. The results is that a company is able to grow at a much more rapid pace.  Focus on existing customers next to new customer is very important when a company wants to grow fast and increase its market share. This can be highly relevant for start-up or scaleup companies or companies which operate in competitive markets. Without focus on existing customers, there is a risk that the company will be overtaken by faster growing competitors, which could result in a loss of market share and profitability of the company.

Summary 

This blog discusses how to create customer value. Customer value is about selling products to existing customers. This can be done by up-selling, cross-selling, renewal-selling or referral selling. There are also several common practices to increase sales, like smart pricing, voucher codes, digital notifications and customer events. Selling to existing customers is cheaper than selling to new customers, because customers can be reached more easily and don’t need to be convinced about the product anymore. In such a way a company can grow faster for less costs. By focusing on existing customers next to new customers, an exponential increase in value can be created. Focus on existing customers is important when a company wants to grow fast and increase its market share.

* = see blog ‘How to turn your online customers’

Using the Sales Funnel to Boost your Sales

sales deal

Companies that are unable to sell their products or services will fail. They will not generate the revenues that cover their costs. But for some companies, especially technically-oriented companies, selling products can be a challenge. What activities do you need to undertake when you want to sell your products? Who is involved in what part of the process? How to measure the success of your sales process? This blog discusses the sales funnel. The sales funnel is a helpful tool to streamline the sales efforts in a company.

The sales-funnel

The sales funnel describes the different phases of the sales process, from awareness creation and prospect creation to sales conversion and relationship building, see the picture below. The reason that a sales funnel is called a funnel is because the process starts with a large amount of (potential) customers and ends with a smaller number of customers who actually buy the product. There are different models of the sales-funnel with different phasing, based on the type of business, for instance whether it concerns the business-to-consumer (B2C) or business-to-business (B2B) market. Some sales-funnel models describe only the phases till the sale of the product, while I think that the later phases also deserve attention, because they are crucial in growing your business. In this blog a simple, generic, model will be presented, which could help you with organizing your sales activity and can be applied to both consumer and business markets.

Sales funnel_090419

Disciplines involved.

In each phase, different activities take place and different disciplines are involved. The most important disciplines are marketing, sales and customer service. Marketing is primarily responsible to define the so-called marketing mix: Product, Price, Place and Promotion (the 4 P’s). The marketing mix provides strategic direction which guides most activities of the sales funnel. Sales is primarily responsible for the customer contacts, sales transactions and follow-up sales. Customer service is primarily responsible for customer support after the sales transaction, but could also have a pre-sales responsibility to provide information about available products. All these disciplines play a crucial role in the sales process. In case of technical products, engineering could also play an important role in the sales process.

The phases of the sales funnel

In the part below, the different phases of the sale-funnel are explained. The phases in the model are described based on the objective of each phase.

Awareness creation

The goal of this phase is to create awareness about your company and the products or services it offers. This can be done in a number of different ways. In the professional business (B2B) this can be done for instance through events or exhibitions, professional magazine ads, newsletters, blogs or whitepapers. In the consumer business (B2C) this can be done through TV, online, magazine or online advertisements, social media, newsletters and blogs. This phase is done primarily by marketing and communication professionals.

Prospect creation

The goal of this phase is to create qualified sales prospects for your products. Prospects are potential customers who are interested in your product. Ideally, this is a two-way approach. First, your company needs to qualify leads. In the business market this is done by creating a prospect list or lead list with potential customers. For each potential customer, the potential value for your company and the effort it takes to win and maintain a customer is estimated. The potential value is determined based on an estimate of the potential sales revenue over the life-time of the customer relationship. The effort is based on the amount of work (hours) it takes to win and service a customer. Now the potential customers can be ranked in the list based on who has the highest value/effort. When the value/effort is too low, these potential customers are not qualified, an no effort is made to get them onboard. In the consumer market a similar approach is followed for potential target groups. The targets groups are ranked based on potential value deviced by the effort to acquire and keep them.

Next, your company needs to convert leads into qualified sales prospects. Qualified sales prospects are prospects which are committed to buying the product. In the business market, this is done to reach out to the sales prospects to present the product or service and to validate whether the product or services meets their needs. It is recommended to reach out to customers early in the development process, to validate whether your assumptions are correct, and to create interest for your product. For complex technical products sometimes tests (‘prove of concepts’) with the customer are done, to demonstrate the benefits of the product. In this phase potential concerns about the product need to be addressed. In consumer markets, commitment by consumers takes place based on direct marketing and promotions, as well as positive test results. For both the consumer and business markets it is important to take the competitive offering into account.

The prospect creation phase is primarily done by sales professionals. For technical products, also product management or engineering is involved. In some models of the sales funnel, the qualification of leads and conversion into qualified sales prospects are described as different phases. In this model, both activities are seen as one phase, because qualification and validation happen more or less in parallel and both activities are needed to come to a list of qualified prospects.

Sales conversion

The goal of this phase is to realize sales of your product. In business markets offers are made to qualified leads. An offer typically consists of the product, its specification, the price and delivery time. In some cases additional negotiations are done. When the offer fits the customer’s needs, the chance is high that this results in a sale. In consumer markets sales is frequently realized through promotions or advertising. After the sales, the product is delivered and installed. When a product is not plug-and-play, additional support could be provided. The delivery and installation is also an important part of the sales process. When the experience is not good, this can lead to product returns. This phase is primarily done by sales and service professionals.

Relationship building 

To generate sales it is easier to create additional sales from existing customers than to find and attract new customers. From this perspective, the phase after sales conversion is an essential phase. This is a phase of the sales-funnel which is frequently forgotten. The goal of this phase is to build relationships with your existing customers and make them loyal to your product or services. In some cases, when the customer is really delighted with your product, the customer could become an ambassador and help to promote your brand and create additional sales. When you have a good relationship with your customers, this will help you to collect feedback about how the customer is using your product and whether the customer is satisfied with it. This helps you to investigate whether the customer is interested in accessorees or additional products and when the customer is ready to buy a new product. Also, in some cases existing customers could help you to define requirements for the next generation of products. This phase is primarily done by sales and marketing professionals.

Product push versus product pull

To optimize the sales process, it is important to understand the difference between product push and product pull. With product push, the company focusses on creating sufficient supply of the product, so that the product is available and can be sold to the customers. Activities are production of products and shipment to the point of sale. With product pull, the company focusses on creating demand for the product. Activities are advertising and promotions, so that the customer asks for the product. It is important to understand that both approaches are sub-optimal. With product push, the product is available, but customers still need to be convinced to buy the product. With product pull, the demand is there, but the product is not available. Both approaches cost energy and are therefore sub-optimal. To create an optimum sales process, focus should be on both product push and market pull. In that case there is both supply and demand, and no energy is lost in the process.

Functional versus emotional benefits

Another important aspect of the sales process is the way the customer is approached: functional versus emotional. Successful sales people are able to operate on both levels. Sales on a functional level is about the sale of the functional benefits of a product. Examples of functional benefits are the ease-of-use and performance of a product. Sales on an emotional level is about the sale of the emotional benefits of a product. Examples of emotional benefits are the brand image or sense of belonging. In some markets, like consumer electronics, watches or clothing, the emotional benefits are as important of even more important as the functional benefits. My personal experience is that some companies have problems to sell their products because they focus only on the functional benefits of a product, but overlook the emotional benefits.

Multi-level sales

The next thing to be aware of is that in some cases sales happens on multiple levels. This is in particular the case in the business market for sales to large companies. In general three levels can be distinguished: the technical level, the commercial level en the (top-)management level. On the technical level the technical specifications are discussed. The goal is to make sure that the product fits with the requirements of the customer. On the commercial level, the commercial aspects are discussed. The goal is to make sure that commercial terms (e.g. price, delivery time) meet the requirements of the customer (e.g. budget, launch time). On top-management level strategic aspects are discussed. The goal is to ensure that a commercial deal does not compromise or supports the higher strategic goals of the customer. A common mistake is that companies sell on one particular level, without taking the wishes of the other levels into account. The result could be that a deal is blocked, because the other levels have certain requirements which are not covered by the offer.

Sales performance measurement

With the sales-funnel, the performance of the sales process can be measured and optimized. The overall goal is to create the most sales with the least effort. All steps can be expressed in measurable performance indicators. They are for instance the % of awareness amongst potential customers, the % of prospects, the % of sales and the % of loyal customers that do repeat sales. Because of the conversion from each phase to the next phase, the % at the start of the process must be high to create sufficient sales at the end of the funnel. Also, the higher the conversion rates are in the subsequent steps, the more sales will be the result.

Summary

In this blog the sales funnel has been introduced. The sales funnel is an excellent tool to manage the sales process. It describes the different phases of the sales process: 1) awareness generation 2) prospect creation 3) sales conversion and 4) relationship building. The process is called a funnel, because it goes from a large amount of potential customers to a small number of customers who actually buy the product. The sales process does not stop at the sales, the relationship building is essential to collect feedback about your product and to create follow-up sales. In the sales process, different disciplines are involved: marketing, sales, customer service. In case of technical products, engineering could be involved as well. They are all needed to create an effective sales funnel. To optimize the flow through the funnel it is important to create both market push and pull. In order to create successful sales, it is important to take both the functional and emotional aspects into account. Also it is important to realise that sometimes sales takes place on multiple levels. When some of the levels are not taken into account, deals run the risk of being blocked.

Engaging Stakeholders for Success

Image stakeholders_110619

When you manage your innovation project, it is important to engage your stakeholders. Stakeholders are persons who are able to influence the outcome of your project or are impacted by the outcome. When you neglect your stakholders, it can mean that some stakeholders will oppose your project, resulting in less effectiveness or even complete failure. This blog presents a framework which helps you to engage your stakeholders. 

Identification of your stakeholders

The first step is to identify your stakeholders. Stakeholders include those people and parties who may be affected by decisions, as well as those who can drive or influence implementation of change. It is important to identify all your stakeholders. Some stakeholders will be supportive of your project, while others may oppose. It happens frequently that stakeholders are overlooked. This is a natural tendency, because innovation in itself requires a lot of dedication. Overseeing one or more stakeholders could mean that their interests are not sufficiently taken into account, why they might turn against you at a later stage.

The best way to identify your stakeholders is to organize a brainstorm session with your team. One of the most important stakeholders is the customer, because the customer pays for your product. Other obvious stakeholders are your suppliers, the employees and the shareholders. There are also other less obvious stakeholders, like regulators, resellers, the local community, the environment and the government.

In some large companies it makes sense to list departments of the company. Let’s assume the project is developed by the Development Department. The stakeholders are some of the other departments: the Marketing Department, the Sales Department, the Customer Service Department, the Production Department, the Purchasing Department, the Quality Department, the Legal and Financial Departments. All these departments might have specific requirements for your project. Some of these departments represent stakeholders outside the company. For instance, the Sales Department represents the customers, the Purchasing Department represents the suppliers and the Financial Department represents the shareholders of the company. In large companies it also make sense to list some of the higher-level managers, especially when they are part of other departments or overarching organizations with their own specific goals.

What do your stakeholders want

The next step is to talk to your stakeholders and discuss their relationship with the project. It is important to identify stakeholder needs and specific stakeholder requirements. So the product requirements (or so-called user-stories for an agile way of working) need to be defined for all stakeholders. For instance, the Production Department wants that the product can be produced in an easy way. The Sales Department wants that the product meets the requirements of your customers. The Purchasing Department wants the product design to be consistent with the specifications of the supplier components. Because requirements can be easily misinterpreted, it is important to verify the listed requirements with your stakeholders directly.

In discussions with your stakeholders, it is also important to discuss and agree on how to involve them. For some stakeholders, it is enough to define requirements at the start of the project and inform them at the end of the project when these have been delivered. For instance, for the Legal department it is important to ensure that certain regulations are taken into account, but they do not need to be involved in every stage of the project. For other stakeholders it is import that they are informed throughout the project. For instance, for the sales department it is important to monitor how the project is progressing and whether there are any delays or changes in the specifications. Common ways to involve stakeholders are to organize common meetings, send them meeting reports or copy them on relevant emails. It is important to collectively agree on how to involve stakeholders, so that both sides feel comfortable.

Engaging your stakeholders

The next step is to engage your stakeholders. Reaching out to them at the start of your project is already a good step to make them supportive of your project. However, this is not enough. Stakeholder engagement is about building a relationship with your stakeholders. Stakeholders could become true business partners, who will pro-actively support you with your project. It is therefore important to continuously engage with them according to the agreed way to involve them. The engagement of stakeholders can be on different levels. To measure the level of engagement, the following classification can be used (in order from low engagement till high engagement):

  • Unaware: does not know about the project
  • Aware: knows about the project, but does not take any action
  • Supportive: collaborates when needed
  • Partner: champions the project, helps you pro-actively

Because circumstances can change over time, it is import to continue to engage with stakeholders to check whether the initial needs and requirements are still valid. It is also important to monitor the engagement levels of your stakeholders over time. This is done for instance once a month and until the goals of the project are realized. When stakeholder requirements change and/or engagement goes down, it is important to take timely action, before stakeholders start to oppose the project.

Stakeholder Engagement Template

The following template is a helpful tool to list all your stakeholders, needs, requirement and how to involve them over time. Ideally this template is filled out at the start of the project with your entire team. My experience is that it is worthwhile to fill this template out by the entire team, so that the whole team becomes aware of the stakeholders and what particular role they play.

Stakeholder Engagement Template_110619

Summary 

This blog discusses the importance of stakeholder engagement. Stakeholders include those people and parties who may be affected by decisions, as well as those who can drive or influence implementation of change. Stakeholders can support your project but also oppose your project, when their needs are not taken into account. That is why it is important to identify all your stakeholders and list their specific needs. It is also important to agree how to involve them. The level of engagement of your stakeholders can vary over time. That is why it is important to monitor and classify stakeholder engagement throughout the project. The goal of stakeholder engagement is to build a good relationship with your stakeholders so that they become real partners. This will increase the success of your project.

 

How to deliver Quality in Digital Innovation


Quality is an important attribute of products. When products do not meet the quality expectations of customers, customers will start to complain and do not buy those products in the future. Traditional quality management methods, like Total Quality Management and Six Sigma, have proven to be very successful for traditional hardware products in stable markets. But how can we manage products and services that consist mostly of software and operate in dynamic markets? Are methods like Agile software development effective to create high quality products?  

Definition of quality

There are many definitions available for the term ‘quality’. The following definition fits best in the context of this blog: ‘Quality is how well a product or service meets the requirements and specifications of the user and/or customer of the product or service’. This definition shows that there are 2 different aspects to quality. One is that quality determines how well a product meets the requirements of the user or customer, also called ‘fitness for use’. This implies that the requirements of the product need to be representative, specific and complete. Sometimes there is a difference between the customer, the person who buys the product, and the user, the person who uses the product, and both can have different requirements which must be taken into account.  

The other aspect is how well a product meets the requirements of the product, also called ‘conformance to requirements’. This implies that the real product or service should meet the requirements. Examples are hardware products which are mass produced and should have minimal variation between them, and services which should be consistent in the execution for all customers. Part of this is the ‘reliability’, which is how well the product continues to perform over time under various user conditions.   

A nice way to describe quality is that the product or service should have the right design and that the design should be right. To summarize this, one could say that quality is about right design right.

The consequences of poor quality

Most people have had the disappointing experience that they bought a cheap product, which went defect soon after they bought the product. And also that the product could not be repaired, so they had to throw the product away. Of course this is a very disappointing situation for the customer. But this is also a bad situation for the company, because there are many negative consequences of poor quality.

Some of the negative consequences are: 1) dissatisfied customers, who will not promote the product and will not buy other products of the company 2) higher operational costs, because there is more waste in the supply chain and in manufacturing 3) higher service costs, because of helpdesk calls or efforts to solve problems 4) lower motivation of company employees, because of inefficiencies and defects and customer complaints 5) negative impact on the environment, because products end up prematurely on landfills, without having been used properly. These consequences show that the focus on good quality in innovation is very important, because it affects many aspects of the business.

Traditional Quality Methods

There are a number of traditional quality methods, including ‘Total Quality Management’, and ‘Six Sigma’. Total Quality Management (TQM) is the continual process of reducing or eliminating defects in the supply chain, in manufacturing, improving the customer experience and ensuring that employees are up to speed with training. TQM states that all parties involved in the production process are accountable for the overall quality of the final product or service. TQM was developed by William Deming (1), a management consultant and lecturer, who had a great impact on Japanese manufacturing just after the Second World War. An important tool in TQM is the Deming Cycle, based on the cycle of Plan, Do, Check and Act.

Six Sigma is a technical, data-driven and statistical quality improvement method to achieve capable business processes, which are processes which meet, given its natural variation, the customer requirements. There are 2 variants of the method: Design for Six Sigma (DfSS) (2), which is focused on the design of products, and Lean Six Sigma, which is focused on organizational improvement. The method was developed in the 1980’s by Motorola in the US. It was initially used in the manufacturing industry, but later also used in the service sector, like banking, insurances and airlines. In all these sectors, Six Sigma has resulted in considerable process improvements and corresponding costs savings.

Both methods use a lot of underlying tools and frameworks, which are used to improve various quality aspects. Examples are Cause and Effect Analysis, Pareto Analysis, Quality Function Deployment, the Kanban system, Just-In-Time inventory management and Statistical Process Control.

Over the past years, all these quality methods and tools have contributed tremendously to the improvement of the quality of products and services. When we buy complex hardware products like a car, a laptop computer of a flat screen TV, the high quality levels of today are achieved thanks to the effectiveness of these quality methods.

The characteristic of the quality methods above is that they work for stable environments. The market is stable, the supply base is stable and customer requirements are stable. This is in particular the situation for hardware products, where the markets and customer requirements used to be relatively stable. These methods do not work in highly dynamic markets with changing customer needs, like the market for software products and services. This is because it is hard to base improvements systems on customer needs and quality metrics which change all the time.

Agile product development

Nowadays, agile product development has become a common practice to develop software. According to this practice the development of software is done by a multifunctional software development team in a series of development sprints, which typically last 2-4 weeks. In each sprint a piece of software resulting in a new functionality is delivered and demonstrated to key stakeholders to collect feedback. Once the functionality is good enough to offer it to real customers, there will be a formal product release. This is done on a frequent basis. In such a way short product iterations are made with room to fail often and early. The agile practice works very well in highly dynamic markets, like the market for software products and services.    

In agile product development product quality is ensured by standard testing of the software to be delivered in a sprint and by frequent collection of feedback once the software has been released to customers. When software is created in the sprint, it is tested in the same sprint, either by test engineers or automatically by testing software. In agile, the requirements for the software are the result of the process, rather than the starting point for development. This way of working is completely different from the traditional methods which are described above. Nowadays, software engineers are mostly not familiar with traditional quality methods, because they are considered not relevant and are not taught in modern software development courses.

Quality in Agile development, what can go wrong?

Now there are some situations, where the agile approach to quality is not sufficient to ensure good quality of the product:

  • Mass produced hardware products with embedded software, like cars, consumer electronics and computers. Because hardware products cannot be developed and produced in an agile process, the 100% agile approach is not suitable. When a 100% agile approach would be followed, this would result in wrong and missing requirements for the hardware and poor process capabilities. A 100% traditional approach is also not suitable because that would prevent the agility needed for these specific markets.
  • Complex software service platforms, which need to deliver a consistent user experience for all customers. Examples are large web shops and entertainment platforms. Because the software runs on hardware servers and because the technology can be very complex, there is a risk of variances in the service performance over time. This could result in disturbances and interruptions of the service or even in a complete breakdown of the platform. In this case a 100% agile approach is not suitable, because it does not take into account process capabilities and monitoring. A 100% traditional approach is also not suitable, because these platforms are mostly operating in dynamic markets with changing customer demands.  

Both cases have in common that the product or service needs to be flexible due to dynamic markets while at the same time consistency in processes are required due to the high number of users or the high number of products which are produced.

A new integrated quality approach

In the cases above a new integrated approach of traditional quality management and agile software development is recommended. In such a way the unique strengths of both traditional quality management and agile product development are combined. I call this a new approach because there is a close interaction between the approaches. An example is that certain fixed design parameters and requirements need to be taken into account when developing new software. Therefore it is important to understand under which  conditions traditional quality management, agile product development or the integrated approach must be used.

The following diagram shows the 2 parameters which determine which approach must be used. One parameter is the variability of the market, whether it is a stable or dynamic market environment. The other parameter is the number of products, whether it is a single product or service for one particular customer or whether it are multiple products or a service to be used by multiple customers.

The bottom left quadrant shows markets for a single product in a stable market. Examples are the building of a house or a custom built yacht. To achieve good quality, traditional quality methods are recommended, especially the development and verification of requirements following the waterfall method. The top left quadrant shows markets for a single product in a dynamic market environment. Examples are the building of a mobile app or a website. To achieve good quality, agile product development is recommended, to provide the flexibility to respond to changing market demands. The bottom right quadrant shows markets for multiple products in a relatively stable environment. Examples are household appliances, garden tools and office utilities. To achieve good quality, traditional quality methods are recommended, especially quantitative methods to achieve good process capabilities.

The quadrant at the top right shows markets with high variability and high volumes of products, like the examples mentioned above. In these markets it is recommended to use a combination of traditional quality methods and agile product development. In this situation fixed quality parameters are defined, which must be delivered in the project and contribute to the quality of the product. At the same time flexible software solutions are developed, which further contribute to the expectations of the customer and the quality of the product. In certain hardware centered industries, like the car industry or the aerospace industry, a digital twin is created, which is a software representation of the hardware product to be build. This digital twin is used for early quality simulations and to collect early feedback of customers before the product is built. This approach allows for more agility in the development of complex hardware products.

From this diagram is can be concluded that in 3 out of the 4 quadrants traditional quality methods remain important to ensure quality in digital innovation. Therefore, software engineers should be trained in these methods, so that they are able to apply them when needed. Especially when they are working on complex systems, like the ones described above. Only then can good quality of a product or service be assured.

Conclusion

Quality is an important attribute of a product or service. Traditional quality methods like Total Quality Management and Six Sigma have been very successful to raise quality levels of products over the past years. Nowadays agile product development has become a common practice to develop software. The quality of software is ensured by test cycles in the sprint and by fast release to the market to collect user feedback. However, there are a number of situations, where agile development is not sufficient to ensure good quality. Examples are mass produced products which consist of both hardware and software, and complex service platforms which need to deliver a consistent user experience for many customers. In such situations a new integrated approach must be used, combining the strengths of both methods. A diagram is presented which indicates which method must be used based on the variability of the market and the number of products or amount of users of a service. From this diagram is can be concluded that traditional quality methods remain important to ensure good quality in digital innovation. Therefore, these methods should become part of the toolbox of a modern software engineer.

References

  1. For details about life and work of William Deming, see https://asq.org/about-asq/honorary-members/deming
  2. ‘Design for Six Sigma, in Technology and Product Development, C.M. Creveling, J.L Slutsky, D. Antis, Jr.

Creating an Advantage with Modularity

When creating a new product or service, it is frequently unclear how the exact market for such a product or service looks like. This is especially the case for disruptive products, for which there is no market yet. In this case it could be beneficial to create a modular product, which is flexible enough to adapt to various market needs. But to create a good modular design, additional work must be done at the start of a project, before normal product development work is started. This blog discusses how to create a modular design, and what are the advantages and disadvantages of doing so.

Modular design versus homogeneous design

Modular design is a design approach which subdivides a system into functional modules that can be independently created/adapted and then used in different systems to drive multiple functionalities. With modular design the individual modules can be built or upgraded independently over time, which gives it the additional flexibility to respond to different or changing market needs.

The opposite of modular design is homogeneous design, where the whole product is built in one piece. This is also called monolithic design. In an homogeneous design all component are integrated into once piece, so when you want to change the design you need to change the whole product.

A special form of modular design is platform design, where product variants are based on a common standardized platform. In this case the platform houses all the common functions, while each product has different functions which are built on top of the platform.  

The choice whether to go for a modular design, homogeneous design or an in-between form is a strategic decision. This is because there are major consequences which do not only affect the product, but also the competitiveness of the business. 

Advantages of modular design

In order to make the right design decisions it is important to understand the advantages and disadvantages of modular design. First, there are a number of advantages to modular design:

-in product development modular design allows for distributed design. This means that the development of the system can be done by independent teams which focus on a specific module and do not need to know the entire product. This is an advantage for the development of complex systems, like a car or an airplane. This is also an important condition for agile product development with multiple scrum teams, or scaled agile development.

-modular design helps to decouple technology development from product development. In high-tech products the competitive advantage is dependent on technological breakthroughs. However, the timing of technological advances is frequently uncertain, which is why it is beneficial to decouple technology development from product development. This is done by concentrating new technologies in specific modules and more general product functions in other modules.  

-modular products can be more adaptive to changing market needs and can be customized more easily. This happens by making new combinations of modules or upgrade certain modules to create new functionality, see figure below. This is especially relevant in markets with fast changing market needs, like the PC markets in which the seize of memories and speed of processors are continuously evolving.

-the product can potentially be cheaper because modules can be reused in future products. New products can be made by making new combinations of modules or by upgrading only certain modules. When developing a new product it is not required to develop all modules from scratch. This results also in a shorter time-to-market.   

-modular design allows for de-verticalization of the supply chain, creating a market for specialized low-cost Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMS’s), which sell their products to multiple, often competing, brands. Because the volumes of OEM products sold are higher, the costs of the components can be lower. A well known example is the industry of consumer electronics products, which uses OEM’s, like Foxconn, to design and produce printed circuit boards.

-modular design in an enabler to create built-to-order assembly. In such a way customers can order products which fit their own needs. A well-known example from the computer industry is Dell, which became highly successful in the 1990’s (ref 1). Dell offered its products on-line directly to the consumer, who could choose product features, like the processor, memory size and screen size, according to their own wishes. Based on these specifications, products were built-to-order. This was possible because of the modular architecture of its products. Because the products were built-to-order and shipped directly to the home of the customer, Dell was able to create a very efficient supply chain, saving inventory costs and retail costs.

-modular design also allows to create environmental-friendly products. When a product is defect, products can be re-furbished by using 2nd hand components. Well-known examples are cars and aircraft using second hand components, or components consisting of recycled materials. In such a way the life-time of products is increased and fewer products are scrapped, reducing the environmental load caused by producing new products.

-it is easier to do maintenance of products. Individual modules showing fatigue can be replaced without renewing the whole system. Also the down-time is reduced, because it is easier to locate problems and repair a module, instead of repairing the entire product.  

-modular designs can be more safe and secure. When there is an accident it will be contained in a specific module and will not propagate through the entire design. The boundaries between modules help to stop the spreading of a mechanical failure of software security problem.

Disadvantages of modular design

There are not only advantages to modular design, but also a number of disadvantages. It is important to be also aware of those:

-slower reaction of the system. Because the performance is dependent on the interaction between different modules, it can sometimes take longer before agreement is reached. This is also called ‘cost of interaction’. The more interactions take place, the longer it can take to realize agreement. When performance is too slow, it helps to make the system more homogeneous to reduce the cost of interaction.

–lower performance of the system. Performance is how well does a certain function, like the speed or acceleration of a car. Modular designs are good for flexibility, but they are not always optimized for performance. In order to create the best performance, the best thing is to create a monolithic design which is completely optimized for performance.

-potentially higher costs of the product. A modular design consists of more parts than a homogeneous design. For some products, like everyday household products, a modular design does not always offer the cheapest product. The cheapest products consist mostly of fewer parts, like injection molded plastics.  

How to create a modular design?

Modular design can be used to design hardware products, electronics or software products. To create a modular design you need 3 building blocks: 1) functional modules 2) an interface to connect the modules 3) rules or protocols to which the modules must comply and which govern the interaction between them.

The first step is to unbundle the monolytic system you envision into separate functions. In computer science this is called separation of concerns. A module can be considered as black box with input and output, without the need to know what happens inside. The connection of the modules happens by the interface. Sometimes the interface is based on industry standards, which makes it possible to use the same components for multiple products. The interaction of the modules happens by rules or protocols. For hardware products a set of rules is used to which the modules must comply, like the size and shapes of the modules. For software products protocols are used, which define the terms, agreement and common language through which the modules interoperate. The goal of good protocols is to reduce the interaction costs between individual modules. Like the interface, protocols are sometimes based on industry standards, which are used for multiple products in an entire industry. Modules can be loosely coupled, which means that the modules have a high degree of autonomy. Or they can be tightly coupled, which means that the modules are more constraint by the interaction with other modules in the system.

To implement a modular design requires additional effort at the start of the project, which could be described as the product architecture phase. A modular design is mostly made by a specialized systems architect, a chief engineer or an experienced development engineer. System engineering is an specific expertise which requires a wholistic approach to design and is different from development or coding. The output of this phase governs the subsequent work of the development teams which develop the modules.   

Optimization of costs

A common challenge for complex software projects is the high costs to develop them and the risk of cost overruns. For those projects it is therefore recommended to optimize the costs as part of the architecture phase. In modular design there are 2 important cost drivers. First there is the cost of developing the modules. Typically, the total development costs decreases when the amount of modules increase. This is because the functions of the individual modules is clearly defined and takes less time to develop and test. Then there is the cost of integrating the modules. Typically, the development cost of integrating the modules increases when there are more modules which need to work together in a system. This is because all possible interactions need to be developed and tested. Now, the total cost of developing a system is the total of the cost of developing the modules and the cost of integrating those modules. When adding these costs up it becomes clear that there is a cost-optimum which is somewhere in the middle. The graph below shows how the lowest costs can be determined.

Examples of modular design

There are many examples of modular design. Probably the best known example, which many people know from when they were young, is Lego. Lego is an example of modular design applied to hardware. Lego consists of standard colored plastic bricks in many different forms and shapes. All bricks have studs on the top and tubes on the inside of the bricks. The bricks are the modules and the studs and tubes form the interface between the bricks. This way it is possible to construct all kind of toys, from cars to houses and spaceships. Compared to electronics and software there is no protocol which governs the bricks (ref 2), other than a set of rules which determines the sizes, materials and colors of the bricks.

A typical example of modular design by using product platforms can be found in the watch industry. A well-known pioneer of platform design in the watch industry is Swatch. Swatch uses standardized product platforms, which form the basis for a variety of watch designs. Each platform consists of the motor, battery and mechanics, all packed in a metal housing. The production of the platforms is highly automated, to be able to create high volumes for very low costs. Now different designs are made by using different arm bands, different watch fronts, pointers and cases. The designs can be regularly updated according market trends and customer needs, without the need to adapt the basic platform of the watch. In such a way, Swatch is able to offer relatively cheap watches with a variety of trendy designs, appealing to the different tastes of its customers.

Another example of modular design is the design of cars. Modular design is frequently applied to create product derivatives and upgrades. For instance, by using standardized interfaces, a car can be fitted with a variety of wheels, engines, seats or luxury items in order to create different car variants. The car industry makes also use of common platforms across various car brands. This is frequently done with the chassis, which is the supporting structure of the car with the engine, gear and wheels. An example is the chassis of the VW Golf, which is also used by the Audi A3 and Skoda Octavia.  

An example of modular design is the design of electronics and information technology products, like TV’s, audio equipment and personal computers. A product consists of one or more multiple printed circuit boards, fitted with standardized components, like resistors, capacities, processors and memories. One or more printed circuit board forms the basis of a product module, like a memory board, a display or a power supply. Several of these modules are mounted in a mechanical housing, which together form the product. In electronics the interfaces between modules or with the outside world are frequently based on industry standards, like USB, UPnP, HDMI or Wifi. 

Modular design is also applied for the design of airplanes and spacecraft. The aerospace industry is driven by technological advancement in order to stay competitive. Frequently the airplane of spacecraft consists of a common platform, called airframe. On this airframe various modules are fitted like the engine, avionics and power supply. This approach helps to increase the lifetime of the product. When new technologies become available, like a new engine or avionics for an aircraft, only these specific modules need to be replaced, instead of buying a completely new aircraft, which is very expensive. For suppliers this approach is also attractive, because they can sell their products to multiple customers which increases volumes and reduces financial risk. Modular design also helps to reduce maintenance costs. When a specific component is defect, it can be easily traced and repaired by changing this component or the specific module of the component.   

Modular knowledge and organizations

Modular design can also be applied to knowledge and organizations (ref 3). This is relevant for knowledge intensive businesses like consulting, financial investment companies or research organizations. In this case standardized knowledge modules are defined and developed which are used in specific combinations for specific customer projects. By using standardized knowledge modules, the knowledge acquisition costs and time-to-market can be reduced and the amount of expertise can be increased. A step further is the design of modular organizations, which consists of organizational building blocks which are optimized for specific tasks. When a company does a project for a customer, a combination of organizational building blocks is used, depending on the goal of the project. By working in this way, the costs and time-to-market can be decreased and expertise can be further increased.     

Conclusion

When creating a new product or service, it is frequently unclear how the exact market for such a product or service looks like. This is especially the case for disruptive products, for which there is no market yet. In this case it could be beneficial to create a modular product, which is flexible enough to adapt to various market needs. Modular design is a design approach which subdivides a system into functional modules that can be independently created/adapted and then used in different systems to drive multiple functionalities. It is a strategic decision whether to go for a modular design, because there are many business consequences.

Modular design has a number of advantages, including more product flexibility, distributed design possibilities, potentially lower products costs, easier maintenance and increased safety and security. However modular design can also have disadvantages, most notably a lower product performance and slower reaction of the system. To implement a modular design requires additional effort at the start of a project. This is mostly done by specialists, like a systems architect or chief engineer. Modular design can also be applied to the acquisition of knowledge or to organizational design.    

References

  1. ‘Direct from Dell: Strategies that Revolutionized an Industry’, Michael Dell, Harper Business, 1999
  2. An exception are some of the modern Lego packs which have built in electronics
  3. ‘Strategic Product Creation: Managing New Interactions of Technology, Markets, and Organizations’, Ron Sanchez, European Management Journal, Vol 14 no 2

How to use Design to Differentiate your Product

Mini_031217

Design is one of the attributes of a product. The importance of design depends on the expectations of the customers in a specific market. In many markets, like household appliances, clothing or cars, design is an important attribute to compete in that market. Without an attractive design, it is harder to sell products. But how do you create the right design for your product?

What is design?

Design is how a product looks and feels. For hardware products, it is determined by the shape of a product, the colors, the materials used and the finishing. The user-interface is generally also considered to be part of design. Design is different from functional product development: creating product functions independent how they look or feel. Real designers will tell you that design is a true art: design gives products a soul and brings products to live.

Design follows functionality

Products are designed for a certain function. For example, a drill is used to create a hole, a coffeemaker is designed to create coffee and a chair is designed to be able to sit on. Good design creates value by supporting the main function of the product. By carefully selecting the shapes, colors, materials, design supports the main function of the product. For instance, a sports car has a small front, an aerodynamic shape and broad wheels, to be able to drive high speeds.

Creating emotional design

Design can be used for more than just functionality. In fact, design can support different levels of the Maslov hierarchy of needs. In different markets, the role of design can be different. In certain mature markets, like the watch industry, functional design is a basic attribute, while real product differentiation is based on emotional design. By selecting certain shapes, materials and colors, design is used to create emotion. Design can be used to create products which look expensive, strong, male, female, trendy, sporty, classic, elegant etc. By linking design features with the needs and aspirations of the target customer segment, the product creates additional value to the customer. The effect is that customers are prepared to pay more for a product which has a good design. Good design gives pricing power.

Signature elements

Signature elements are used to establish a link with the brand. Signature elements are certain design elements or details that are present on each product of the brand, like the specific grille of a BMW, the technical perfection look of a Dyson vacuum cleaner or the round home button on Apple devices. These signature elements do not, or hardly, change over time. By using these signature elements, it is easy to recognize that a specific product belongs to a brand, even for products which have been produced many years ago.

Design varies over time

In some markets, like the fashion industry, design tastes and trends are changing rapidly, while in some other markets, like household appliances, design changes at a much slower pace. When designing a product it is important to be aware of market trends. With respect to market trends, one can choose different approaches: 1) to be a trendsetter 2) to follow the market or 3) to be a slow follower. The approach should be consistent with the brand. When a company is an innovative trendsetter, this must be reflected in design by using innovative designs which are followed by competitors. When a product is a low cost producer, it is sufficient to be a slow follower in design.

Building design competencies

When design is an important factor in your business, it is important to make sure that you build design competencies for your company. It starts with hiring design specialists. Design is a real specialism. There are different kind of designers, like for instance strategic designers, product designers and user-interaction designers.

Also, a proper design process needs to be implemented which is complementary to the product development process. The classical design process, which is for instance used in the car and consumer electronics industries, is an annual cycle which consists of different phases:

  • Identify key design trends which are relevant for your launch window
  • Select a design direction or strategy which is most relevant for your target market and corresponds with your brand
  • Create some design concepts and test them with prospective customers
  • Select the best design concept and create a detailed design
  • After market launch: evaluate the design performance

By following a structured design process, the chance that a design becomes successful is increased.

Design contests

Because of the importance of design in certain markets, like the consumer electronics industry, recognition by external design experts is important. Design contests, like the famous Red Dot or IF Design awards, are used to push the boundaries of design. But they also help to communicate the quality of design to the market, for instance by using the logo of the design awards on packaging and the products.

Summary

The design is how a product looks or feels. The design of a product consists of the shape, colors, materials and finishing. Design is used to support different levels of the Maslov hierarchy of needs. Some design is primarily functional: it supports the basic function of the product. In other cases design is used to play a more emotional role: it makes the user feel better.

When you operate in a certain market, always check the relevance of design. The importance of design depends on the expectations of the customers in a certain market: is it a nice-to-have or a key factor of competition? When design is a key factor of competition, it is important to build design competencies for your organization. This is done by hiring designers and getting a design process in place which is complementary to the product development process.

In markets where design is important, good design creates value. Products with a good design can be sold at a higher price than product with a poor design.

How to manage the Cash Flow Curve

skateboard_021016

In innovation-oriented companies finance is frequently overlooked. Finance is frequently a separate domain outside the direct responsibility of the engineers and marketers who drive innovation in a company. The result is that important dependencies are overlooked, which can result in serious cash flow problems or even bankruptcy of a company. In this blog a framework is presented called the ‘Cash Flow Curve’, which helps innovators to manage the financial aspects of innovation.

Introducing the Cash Flow Curve

The Cash Flow Curve shows the cumulative cash flows over time. On the horizontal axis the time is given and on the vertical axis the cumulative cash flow is given. The cumulative cash flow is the sum of all the positive cash flows -money in- and negative cash flows -money out- related to a project. To explain the Cash Flow Curve, let us now have a look at how the Cash Flow Curve behaves over time for a single project, see the image below.

Cash Flow Curve_110619

In general, we can distinguish 3 different investment phases of the Cash Flow Curve:

The first phase is called the initial investment phase. In this phase investors give money to start a new project. In this phase just money is spent and no revenues are coming in. So the cumulative cash flow is negative and gets more negative over time. When an innovation hits the market and is sold to customers, revenues are coming in. This means that the slope of the cumulative cash flow curve becomes less negative over time.

The second phase is the profitability phase. When a product becomes profitable, the incoming revenues are higher than the product costs and organizational costs. This results in a positive cash flow, which is visible in an upward cumulative cash flow curve.

The depth of the curve indicates the amount of capital a company needs to finance the project. The lowest point of the curve is the maximum capital a company needs to finance for the project. After this point, the company can gradually start to pay some of the investors or lenders back, but frequently still needs cash for upscaling of the business.

The third and last phase is the period of return. This phase starts when the cumulative cash flow is zero, which means that the earned cash equals the invested cash in the project. This point is also called the cash break-even point. In this phase there is enough money earned to pay back the investors, and subsequent cash can be used to invest in further growth of the business. Note: the cash break-even point is not the same as the economic profit, which is frequently used by investors, because it takes the cost of capital into account.

Sometimes it lasts very long before the third phase is reached, because it can last very long before a product becomes profitable. Some products become even never profitable, because the product-market fit is not right. In some cases this is not always visible from the outside and investors keep pouring money in. These companies are called zombie companies. In this case the investors shares are diluting and investors will never receive their money back. It can also happen that a profitable company becomes unprofitable over time. This could be because of changing market conditions. In some cases assets become less worth and need to be written off. We call these also stranded assets. For investors this means that their share becomes less worth.

Startup companies versus mature companies

The Cash Flow Curve is valid for both start-up companies as well as mature enterprises: the same financial laws apply. The key difference is that start-up companies frequently use external financing, while most mature enterprises use internal financing for new projects, like cash from mature product lines which is re-invested in future opportunities. That is why frequently financial resources look ‘unlimited’, and finance gets less attention. Also finance in large enterprises is frequently handled by a different department, and is as such less visible. But this does not mean that cash management is less important in mature companies.

Financing the project

Funding for the project can be done by internal or external sources. Internal sources can be the founders or the company itself, in case of mature companies which reinvest profits in new projects. External sources can be for instance angel investors, venture capital funds or banks.

Getting external finance is not always easy. In fact it can take a long period of time to convince investors or banks that your product of service is good to invest in. There are different types of investors, depending on the investment phase a company is in. The following table gives an overview of the different phases of a project and typical finance sources per phase.

Financing sources_110619

A company needs to organize investment rounds to find the external investment it needs. In every finance round, there can be multiple investors. My personal experience with start-ups is that the time and effort it takes to get new investors on board is frequently underestimated. It can sometimes take several months to get new investors on board. This is especially the case for professional investors, like venture capital funds or strategic investors. Sometimes it happens that projects need to be put on hold, because there is no money available to continue the work.

Burn rate and runway

To manage cash flow throughout the Cash Flow Curve it is important to know 2 critical parameters: the burn rate and runway. This is especially important for start-up companies. The burn rate is the amount of cash you use in a given time frame. Let’s say the burn rate of start-up X is USD 200K per month. The runway is the amount of time before a company is running out of cash. Let’s assume that a company got USD 500K from investors and spent already 1 month of work. Assuming a burn rate of USD 200K per month, there is USD 300K left, which is a runway of 1.5 month. That could mean that this company needs to start to look for investors soon.

Summary

Cash is like the life blood of a business. Every business needs to have sufficient cash. And for innovative businesses this is even more critical, as they need to invest in new opportunities. When there is no timely cash available, a business can run into trouble or even go bust. For innovators it is therefore important to understand the Cash Flow Curve of projects. The Cash Flow Curve shows the cumulative cash flows generated by projects over time. Innovators need to make sure there is timely financing available, which is provided by different parties, depending on the stage of a project. During the entire project it is important to know the burn rate and runway of your project, in order to know when to start looking for new financing. Starting too late means that you run out of cash and have to put projects on hold. When you manage the Cash Flow Curve as an integral part of your innovation process, it increases the chance of success considerably.

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free